Preview

Medical alphabet

Advanced search
Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Legal aspects of the responsibility of a dentist or surgeon when making a medical error

https://doi.org/10.33667/2078-5631-2025-10-126-129

Abstract

Currently, healthcare is shifting to value-based approaches to providing medical care. This expands the rights of citizens in the field of accessibility of medical services and improves their quality. For healthcare, this approach is expressed not just in optimizing financial resources, but in using them wisely, thanks to the flexibility of the system. Unfortunately, providing medical care in some cases can harm the patient. There are many reasons for this. The doctor may make a mistake both at the stage of diagnosis and at the stage of treatment. There is no universal classification of medical errors that fully covers their types in the context of each individual specialty, the causes of the commission, the impact on the outcome, etc. In the article, we model and consider the situation of removal by a dentist-surgeon of a healthy tooth. The analysis of the doctor’s actions and their consequences, the probability and amount of compensation for material and moral damage caused. The possibility of pre-trial resolution of conflicts between the patient and the dental clinic is considered. The identification and study of the structure of defects in medical care provides opportunities to reduce the likelihood of medical error and, consequently, improve the quality of medical care to the population. Medicine is developing, so the term medical error requires not just a modern view, but also official recognition as a problem. It is necessary to supplement and clarify it, for ease of use in official medical documents.

About the Authors

S. V. Dronov
Volgograd State Medical University
Russian Federation

Dronov S.V. – Assistant of the Department of Surgical Dentistry and Maxillofacial Surgery,

Volgograd



V. V. Shkarin
Volgograd State Medical University
Russian Federation

Shkarin V.V. – Doctor of Medical Sciences, Professor, Head of the Department of Public
Health and Health Institute of Continuing Medical and Pharmaceutical Education,

Volgograd



Yu. A. Makedonova
Volgograd State Medical University
Russian Federation

Makedonova Yu.A. – Doctor of Medical Sciences, Professor, Head of the Department of
Dentistry, Institute of Continuing Medical and Pharmaceutical Education,

Volgograd



E. N. Yarygina
Volgograd State Medical University
Russian Federation

Yarygina E. N. – Candidate of Medical Sciences, Associate Professor, Head of the Department of Surgical Dentistry and Maxillofacial Surgery,

Volgograd



A. S. Serbin
Volgograd State Medical University
Russian Federation

Serbin A.S. – Candidate of Medical Sciences, Associate Professor of the Department of
Surgical Dentistry and Maxillofacial Surgery,

Volgograd



M. V. Zakurdaeva
Volgograd State Medical University
Russian Federation

Zakurdaeva M.V. – Assistant of the Department of Surgical Dentistry and Maxillofacial
Surgery,

Volgograd



References

1. Makhambetchin M.M., Shakeev K.T. Some aspects of the theory of doctors’ mistakes // Healthcare of the Russian Federation. 2021;2:159–165.

2. Pogodina T.G., Soboleva M.V. Methodology of expert research of medical errors // Legal technology. 2022;16:486–489.

3. Savoshikova E.V. Defects in medical care: legal consequences of professional incompetence // Russian Journal of Legal Research. 2018;12(4):64–69.

4. Popova T.G. Examination of professional errors and adverse outcomes in dentistry // Forensic medical examination. 2008; 3:35-37.

5. Pashina I.V., Simonyan R.Z. The right of every person to health protection and medical care // Modern problems of science and education. 2015;4:414.

6. Sedova N.N., Proshin P.V., Filimonov A.A. Ethical and legal ways of conflict resolution in dental practice // Medical law. 2019;1:17.

7. Dergunov D.N. Characteristic features of court cases in the field of dentistry// Organizational and legal issues and medical expert activity. 2007;2:5–15.

8. Afanasyeva O.Yu., Kirpichnikov M.V., Yarygina E.N. The possibilities of using mediation as an alternative method of conflict resolution in dentistry // Russian judge. 2014;10:6–9.

9. Popova T.G. Criteria for expert assessment of professional errors and defects in medical care at all stages of dental treatment //Issues of expertise and quality of medical care. 2008; 8:18–24.

10. Simonyan R.Z., Zelenova I.V. Legal regulation in medicine: insurance of professional errors of dentists // International Journal of Applied and Fundamental Research. 2015;2(1):187–189.

11. Imomov S.T. Inadequate medical care due to diagnostic errors // Achievements of Science and Education, 2020;2(56):68–70.


Review

For citations:


Dronov S.V., Shkarin V.V., Makedonova Yu.A., Yarygina E.N., Serbin A.S., Zakurdaeva M.V. Legal aspects of the responsibility of a dentist or surgeon when making a medical error. Medical alphabet. 2025;(10):126-129. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.33667/2078-5631-2025-10-126-129

Views: 61


ISSN 2078-5631 (Print)
ISSN 2949-2807 (Online)